Safety Scores

How to Keep a Clean CSA Safety Score as a New Trucking Company

Brokers, shippers, insurers and FMCSA all look at your safety record, and a new carrier's first few inspections carry a lot of weight. There is no such thing as a perfect score you can buy or file for, but there is a clean record: no violations, clean inspections and no preventable crashes. This guide explains how CSA scores work and the habits that keep yours clean.

  • 5 min read
  • Updated November 3, 2026
  • 10 sections
Safety inspector kneeling to check the steer tire of a blue semi truck while the driver waits with paperwork

What CSA and SMS are

CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability) is FMCSA's safety enforcement program. Its scoring tool, the Safety Measurement System (SMS), uses your roadside inspection results, crash reports and investigation findings from the last 24 months to rank your company against carriers of similar size and activity.

Your SMS results are not the same as a safety rating. A safety rating (Satisfactory, Conditional or Unsatisfactory) comes only from an FMCSA compliance review; most carriers are unrated. SMS percentiles change every month as new inspections and crashes come in.

The 7 BASICs and their thresholds

SMS sorts your data into seven categories called BASICs. Each gets a percentile from 0 to 100, and lower is better. If you go above the intervention threshold, FMCSA may send a warning letter, target you for more roadside inspections or start an investigation.

BASICWhat counts against youThreshold (general property carriers)
Unsafe DrivingSpeeding, reckless driving, improper lane change, phone use, no seat belt65%
Hours-of-Service ComplianceOver hours, missing or false logs, ELD problems65%
Crash IndicatorReportable crashes (tow-away, injury or fatality)65%
Vehicle MaintenanceLights, brakes, tires, defects, missing inspection records80%
Controlled Substances/AlcoholDrug or alcohol use or possession80%
Driver FitnessInvalid CDL, no medical certificate, unqualified driver80%
Hazardous Materials ComplianceHazmat packaging, placards, shipping papers80%

Passenger carriers and hazmat carriers have lower (stricter) thresholds. FMCSA's SMS methodology document lists them all.

Driver with a flashlight checking the brakes behind the front wheel of a red semi truck at dawn

Up next

How the score is calculated

3 of 10 sections

How the score is calculated

  • Only the last 24 months count. Violations from the last 6 months count three times as much as violations 12 to 24 months old.
  • Each violation has a severity weight. Serious violations, and violations that put the driver or vehicle out of service, count more.
  • Most BASICs divide your violations by the number of relevant inspections, so clean inspections help bring your measure down.
  • Unsafe Driving and the Crash Indicator are measured against your size (power units and miles), so keep your MCS-150 mileage and truck count accurate.
  • You are compared with carriers that have a similar number of inspections or crashes. With very little data, a BASIC may show no percentile at all.

Why new carriers must be careful

A new carrier has few inspections, so one bad inspection can push a BASIC far up, while a large fleet barely notices one violation. Your first year also includes the New Entrant Safety Audit, where some violations can make you fail automatically.

Insurers price your renewal partly on your inspection history, and brokers check out-of-service rates before they book you. A clean first year makes everything after it cheaper and easier.

Who can see your scores

Since the FAST Act of 2015, the percentiles and alerts for most property carriers are hidden from the public. Your inspection and violation details, crashes and out-of-service rates are still public on SAFER and the SMS website, and brokers and insurers read them. You can see all of your own percentiles by logging in to the FMCSA portal.

Truck driver smiling at the wheel of a modern cab

Up next

Daily habits that keep your record clean

6 of 10 sections

Daily habits that keep your record clean

  1. 1Do a real pre-trip inspection every day. Lights, tires and brakes are among the violations inspectors find most often.
  2. 2Fix defects before you drive, and write them up on a driver vehicle inspection report (DVIR).
  3. 3Keep the cab ready: CDL, medical certificate, registration, insurance, ELD instruction card, malfunction sheet and blank paper logs.
  4. 4Drive the speed limit, wear the seat belt and keep the phone hands-free.
  5. 5Plan every day around hours of service so no one is tempted to push the clock.
  6. 6Keep the annual inspection current for every truck and trailer.

At a roadside inspection

  • Be calm, polite and organized. Have documents ready and know how to transfer your logs from the ELD.
  • Do not argue on the roadside. If something is cited wrongly, note the details and challenge it later.
  • Ask for a copy of the report before you leave, including clean inspections.
  • If the report lists violations, fix them, sign it and return it to the issuing agency within 15 days.

A clean inspection is good news for your score. Many carriers ask drivers to send every report to the office, clean or not, so nothing gets missed.

Check your scores every month

  1. 1Log in to the FMCSA portal and open your SMS results. They update monthly.
  2. 2Read every new inspection and violation. Are they yours, and are they correct?
  3. 3Look for patterns: the same truck, the same driver or the same violation again.
  4. 4Make sure your MCS-150 details (address, mileage, number of trucks) are up to date.
  5. 5Challenge mistakes in DataQs quickly, while the details are fresh.
Silver semi truck on a mountain road in autumn

Up next

Fixing mistakes with DataQs

9 of 10 sections

Fixing mistakes with DataQs

DataQs is FMCSA's free system for challenging inspection, violation and crash data. You explain what is wrong and attach evidence such as repair receipts dated before the inspection, ELD records, photos, a police report or a court dismissal. The state that did the inspection reviews the request.

For certain crash types, such as being struck from behind or hit by a driver going the wrong way, you can also ask FMCSA through DataQs to decide whether the crash was preventable. You need the police accident report. Crashes found not preventable are marked that way and left out of your Crash Indicator calculation.

Changes coming to SMS

FMCSA approved a revised SMS methodology in late 2024. It renames the BASICs as safety categories, regroups violations and changes how scores are calculated. As of this guide's review date, FMCSA has not switched the new method on and current results still use the seven BASICs. Check FMCSA's CSA website for the current method and any launch date. The habits in this guide keep your record clean under either method.

Free PDF

The CSA Safety Score Playbook

The daily, monthly and after-inspection habits that keep a new carrier's FMCSA safety record clean: pre-trip checks that target the most common violations, an inspection-day checklist, how to review your scores and how to challenge mistakes in DataQs.

  • The 7 BASICs and their intervention thresholds on one page
  • A pre-trip checklist built around common roadside violations
  • What to do during and after a roadside inspection
  • A monthly 15-minute score review
  • Step-by-step DataQs challenge and crash preventability guide

Step 1 of 2

Do you already have a USDOT number?

Either way the PDF is free. Your answer helps us send you what is useful next.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good CSA score?

Lower is better. The goal is to stay well below the intervention thresholds: 65 percent for Unsafe Driving, Hours-of-Service and the Crash Indicator, and 80 percent for the other BASICs for general property carriers. A new carrier with only clean inspections may show no percentile at all, which is fine.

How long do violations stay on my CSA record?

Inspections and violations count toward SMS for 24 months, and their weight drops over time. Recent violations (the last 6 months) count three times as much as those 12 to 24 months old.

Do clean inspections improve my CSA score?

Yes, for most BASICs. Violations are divided by the number of relevant inspections, so more clean inspections lower your measure.

Can I remove a violation from my record?

Only if it is wrong or you have evidence it should not have been cited. File a request in DataQs with documents that support it. A valid violation stays on the record until it ages out after 24 months.

Is a CSA score the same as a safety rating?

No. SMS percentiles change monthly based on inspections and crashes. A safety rating (Satisfactory, Conditional or Unsatisfactory) is given only after an FMCSA compliance review, and most carriers are unrated.

Can brokers see my CSA scores?

Most property carriers' percentiles are hidden from the public, but your inspections, violations, crashes and out-of-service rates are public, and brokers and insurers check them.

Resources

Free downloads, official forms and tools for this topic.

Official sources

Rules and fees change. Check the current figures on these official pages before you file anything.

This page is general information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Fees and rules change; confirm current amounts with each agency. Last reviewed November 3, 2026.

Keep reading

Want us to handle it?

Open Trucking Company files the paperwork, tracks your renewals and keeps your records audit-ready, so you can get on the road.